The Lantern Case, Chapter 1: Fresh From Paradise
The full story cards of this chapter, in the order the game plays them. Spoilers ahead: every episode ends on its twist.
Episode 1 A Sour Welcome
What it looks like
A thief broke into the lantern house.
PinaTourist. Wonderful.
The Finale didn't fire, my lantern's gone,
and they send me a tourist.
Kit the KeyPina. Be nice.
She's like this with everyone. (It's affection, really.)
PinaHe says 'welcome back' to newborns. I say 'go away.'
Look at the lantern house if you must. Then leave.
There's nothing here for a tourist.
AppleDon't come in. This is the scene.
Mum says nobody touches anything.
Kit the KeyThe drawer, would you? No thumbs.
There. The lantern hook.
Empty. Clean. Not a speck of dust.
Kit the KeyNo scratches. No splinters. Nobody forced this door.
Somebody unlocked it. Walked in. Walked out.
With a key.
How it turns out
Nobody broke in. The door was unlocked with a key.
Episode 2 The Pear's Story
What it looks like
Pina is the victim.
The Golden PearI'm old, not blind.
Midnight, my porch, same as every night. Waiting for the Finale.
Somebody went by hugging a lantern. Wrapped in a tablecloth.
Kit the KeyToward the gate?
Did you see a face?
The Golden PearNo face. A crown of leaves.
One person in this park wears one of those.
AppleDon't. Please.
She hasn't slept since that night.
PinaGo on, say it. Everyone's thinking it.
Yes. It was me.
PinaStolen? Nobody steals from me.
I wrapped it up and carried it out myself.
I gave it away.
How it turns out
The Pear saw Pina carry her own lantern out at midnight.
Episode 3 Gave It to Whom
What it looks like
Pina stole her own lantern.
PinaWho I gave it to is my business.
Ask again and you leave this park as jam.
Apple(psst)
She got a letter the day before. It came early.
Before the mail boat. Nothing comes before the boat.
Kit the KeyA letter? Pina. Nobody writes to Pina.
Unfold it for me? Gently.
Pina"Tonight the lanterns stay home.
K."
Kit the Key...K.
PinaLook at the loops on that K. Like a lasso.
Who writes like that? Nobody. Nobody writes to us at all.
Not since the Keeper left.
PinaThe Keeper's back. The Keeper asked. I did as I was asked.
And stop looking at Kit like that.
He can't even hold a pen.
How it turns out
A letter signed "K" told her to keep the lanterns home. Pina says the Keeper is back.
Episode 4 Stay Home, Not Give Away
What it looks like
Pina disobeyed the letter.
Kit the Key"Stay home," it says.
And you carried it out through the front gate.
Pina. That's the opposite of home.
PinaWhose home?
My park was never its home.
I only kept it.
The Golden PearShe's right, for once.
None of the eight were born in the park they hang in.
Kit the KeyThen where...
PinaWhere it was made. Where it was warm.
The oven.
Sugar Kingdom.
How it turns out
Home is not her park. The lantern was born in an oven in Sugar Kingdom.
Episode 5 Overripe
What it looks like
Pina is rotten, and you are a tourist.
Pina"Rotten." That's what my sign says.
Rotten, nothing. I'm ripe.
I've been ripe longer than any of them have been anything.
PinaEight of us built this fair. I was here before the paint.
I remember the Keeper. I remember the Finale when it was loud.
I remember the last guest. And I remember this morning.
Kit the KeyPina...
The Golden PearThe gate lamps. Look.
They lit when this one walked in from the Lighthouse.
Years since they've been this bright. Years.
PinaCome back tomorrow, tourist. The night shift is short a pair of hands.
One more thing. My lantern house has exactly one key.
He is it. Ask him whose door he opened that night.
Kit the Key...I did what little I could that night.
I opened Pina's door. Then Pan's, Scorpio's, Ember's,
Krak's, Hoot's, Dusty's, Crumb's. All eight. Before midnight.
Kit the KeyI was asked to.
A key doesn't say whose door. Not even to you.
...Pan's next. Come on.
How it turns out
She is the oldest of the eight. The gate lamps lit as you passed. And Kit opened all eight doors.