The Lantern Case, Chapter 3: Secrets of the Nile

The full story cards of this chapter, in the order the game plays them. Spoilers ahead: every episode ends on its twist.

Episode 1 The Eye Sees All

What it looks like

At last, a witness.

The Watching Eye

The Eye sees all.

The Eye sees the one the key brought. A tourist, two days here.

The Eye does not testify to tourists.

Kit the Key

It talks like that to everyone.

Hold the night lamp up for me? It likes to be looked at.

The Watching Eye

On Finale night the Eye saw the key open the tower door.

It took the lantern in its arms, raised it high,

and walked away down the dune.

Kit the Key

...In my arms.

Kit the Key

Look at me. You have pressed every button for me since day one.

I could not carry a lantern if I begged.

So what did the Eye really see that night?

How it turns out

The Eye swears Kit carried the lantern off in his arms. Kit has no arms to carry with.

Episode 2 Night Blind

What it looks like

The Eye is lying to frame Kit.

Kit the Key

Close the shutter on that lamp for me? No thumbs.

Good. Now ten quiet steps to the left.

The Watching Eye

The Eye sees you still, tourist. Standing right there.

The Eye sees the doubt on your face.

Scorpio

It is talking to an empty patch of sand.

Forty one years. Every night the same.

The Watching Eye

...Without a lamp, the Eye cannot see.

That night all eight lanterns were gone.

The Eye saw nothing.

Scorpio

Then why name the key?

The Watching Eye

Everyone says it was the key.

The Eye only says it from higher up.

Kit the Key

You were up there all night.

What did you hear?

The Watching Eye

Sand. It has fallen for forty one years. The Eye sleeps to it.

That night, before midnight, it stopped.

What stops an hourglass?

How it turns out

With no lamp lit, the Eye sees nothing at night. It named Kit because everyone does. But it heard the sand stop.

Episode 3 The Sands of Time

What it looks like

Time is cursed in this park.

Scorpio

Every clock in my park stopped on the same minute.

Eleven forty. I counted.

Scorpio

The key came. One turn. I put it in. One more turn.

I asked for both.

Kit the Key

There. In the neck of the glass.

Don't reach in. Look at the sand above it.

Scorpio

Its glow was no bigger than a date stone when I hid it.

Now it lights the sand like honey.

Scorpio

One grain. The first to fall since eleven forty.

It fell when this one stepped close.

Why would my sand move for a tourist?

How it turns out

The lantern is wedged in the neck of the great hourglass. And one grain fell when you walked up.

Episode 4 The Scorpion's Letters

What it looks like

The Keeper really is back.

Scorpio

It came under my door on Finale morning.

"Tonight the lanterns stay home. K."

I thought he was back. I thought my counting was done.

Kit the Key

Same loops. Same lasso.

That makes three.

Scorpio

This one I keep in a stone box. Forty one years and three months.

"Mind the hours for me. I won't be long. K."

Kit the Key

Lay them side by side for me? Edge to edge.

Scorpio

His hand is all straight lines. Not one loop.

His K comes down like a nail.

Scorpio

Whoever wrote the new letters learned his name.

They never learned his hand.

So whose word did we hide our lanterns for?

How it turns out

Scorpio kept the Keeper's own letter for forty one years. The hand is nothing like the new ones. The new letters are forged.

Episode 5 The Watch

What it looks like

Kit has no idea who forged the letters.

Kit the Key

...I know this hand.

Scorpio

Which.

Kit the Key

The one with the loops.

I have known it since Pina's letter.

Scorpio

Who.

Kit the Key

Ask me again at the Lighthouse.

Scorpio

I do not keep names. I keep hours.

This one is the first to move my sand since eleven forty.

Kit the Key

Every door is mine to keep. Every door but one.

...Carry the lamp for me? It is nearly dawn.

The Watching Eye

The Eye takes back the word tourist. Pina's night-shift hand.

The key knows who wrote to us, and will not say it here.

What is waiting at the Lighthouse?

How it turns out

Kit knew the hand from the first letter and will only answer at the Lighthouse. The Eye takes back the word tourist.